It doesn’t take a special agent to see that Jonathan Groff is one insanely attractive human being. While the actor is currently causing a fan frenzy with his steamy scenes on Netflix’s Mindhunter, it certainly isn’t the first time he has swept us off our feet. Seriously, who else was obsessed with his Glee character, Jesse St. James? Swoon. Whether he’s busting out show tunes on stage or hitting the red carpet in a dapper suit, it’s clear that Jonathan is just way too adorable for his own good. Feast your eyes on his hottest moments ahead.